Season 3 of The Traitors is perfection. The new season gave us everything we could want, including betrayals, vicious roundtable discussions, and Tom Sandoval singing off-key for an entire challenge. It was perfection!
The season is winding down, which means I am already thinking about my dream cast list for Season 4. There are so many iconic reality TV stars who have yet to step foot in Alan Cumming’s castle. To cope with my “Traitors is Ending” depression, I compiled a list of stars I want to see in the next season.
Here we go.
Paige DeSorbo – Summer House
Summer House star Paige DeSorbo is a perfect fit for the Peacock show. The Giggly Squad host is well-versed in the art of confrontation from her many years on Bravo and I know she would kill it at a roundtable. Her keen intuition for sussing out BS would make her a successful Faithful. I can picture her forming an alliance of strong, trustworthy women to take to the end. In addition to her sleuthing skills, she’s a fashionista, which makes her a worthy houseguest in Alan’s Scottish abode. I know her outfits would be to die for. Peacock, give her the call!
Nick Viall – The Bachelor
Nick Viall lovesss reality TV gossip as evident by his hugely successful podcast The Viall Files. The former Bachelor loves to dissect reality stars’ behavior and give his two cents on his favorite shows. I think these qualities make him a great fit for the Peacock show. I believe Nick, like Paige, would be a great Faithful. He’s a great talker and I have no doubt he will be able to sway players at the roundtable.
JaNa Craig – Love Island USA
JaNa Craig won fans’ hearts on Love Island USA and I feel confident she would do the same on The Traitors. Her affable personality and sense of humor would help her excel as a Faithful or a Traitor. JaNa’s Love Island co-stars often confided in her and went to her for advice, which leads me to believe she could be quite a dangerous player on The Traitors. I feel she would be someone people trust in the castle and therefore, she would have a lot of power in deciding who stays, and who goes.
Andy Rueda – Survivor
Andy Rueda played a masterful and messy game on Survivor. I haven’t enjoyed watching a player that much in years. His game was spontaneous, unexpected, and overall, a blast to watch. Andy played such an iconic game that it would be a shame if he was a one-hit wonder. We need him on another reality show. I believe he would be a great addition to The Traitors family. I doubt he would be able to evade banishment for long but I would love to see him try.
Gizelle Bryant – Real Housewives of Potomac
We need Gizelle Bryant on Season 4 of The Traitors. The Bravo star is known for causing drama, making her a natural fit for the Peacock show. I’m not confident in her ability to sus out Traitors (she hasn’t always been the best judge of character), but I know she would keep the roundtables interesting with her endless shady comments and iconic one-liners.
Will Kirby – Big Brother
Will Kirby stopped by the castle in Season 2 to host a challenge but has yet to join the game. The reality TV legend is known for his ability to outsmart and manipulate his fellow competitors, so it seems like a no-brainer to cast him on the Peacock show. The Big Brother winner spoke about his decision to refrain from the series when he criticized BB players who performed poorly on the show.
“Well, I don’t think it’s any secret that the four Big Brother contestants on the first two seasons of The Traitors have done poorly, and I hope the fans don’t chastise me making that factual statement,” he told Entertainment Weekly. “See, I think some Big Brother players went on The Traitors to show that they ‘still got it’ — only to realize that they actually ‘never had it.’”
Rachel LaMont – Survivor
Rachel LaMont played a flawless game on Survivor 47 and I feel certain she would find success on The Traitors. She’s a master strategist and knows how to read her fellow players. I believe Rachel would succeed in any role she’s given on the Peacock show. I suspect she could make it to the end as a Traitor or a Faithful.
The Traitors is available to stream on Peacock.
TELL US – DO YOU AGREE WITH OUR LIST? WHO WOULD YOU CAST ON SEASON 4 OF THE TRAITORS?