In the well-made but unnecessarily long prequel The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, we get a rinse-and-repeat story that is about as predictable as they come. That’s not necessarily a bad thing.
Also known as How Haymitch Became An Alcoholic, this new Hunger Games jumps back in time to tell the story of a young man who we know will be selected to represent District 12, fight and kill other kids, become the annual victor, return home, start drinking, and turn into Woody Harrelson. Rough life, or awesome life, depending on how you look at it.
While the movie attempts to throw a few surprises at us, things happen more or less as you’d expect—for better or worse.
The movie at least looks great. Francis Lawrence, who has directed every Hunger Games movie except for the original (Catching Fire is still, by far, the best), delivers a polished and relatively entertaining action-drama that once again draws us into the lives of teenagers destined to be slaughtered. Despite being two hours and 38 minutes long for some reason, it operates at a solid pace that thankfully feels shorter.
Joseph Zada proves to be a charismatic and energetic protagonist, properly portraying a young Haymitch/Woody. He does incredible voice work to sound eerily similar to the veteran actor (at one point, I almost thought they had dubbed over his voice), but the performance never plays like a caricature. He carries the film with surprising ease and gravitas, even if it comes at the expense of Mckenna Grace, who is more than ferocious enough to headline her own Hunger Games movie but who isn’t given quite enough to do once things once the bloodletting begins.
Hardcore fans of The Hunger Games will find plenty to enjoy here, but it sure feels like this franchise has run its course when it comes to doing anything new. It’s just all so predictable, especially given that we know Haymitch will survive and become the drunk he becomes. Lawrence seems to have gotten a little bored of the games, too—more of the action happens off camera, with most of the deaths caused by “unnatural” disasters. When the movie does attempt to break from its trappings, the moments are fleeting, even convenient.
Which makes the long run time all the more baffling. Even though the film’s pace is good enough, the sixth movie in a franchise about kids killing other kids arena-style should be pretty damn lean and mean at this point. Lawrence spends too much time dwelling on filler moments that could have been cut; there’s a whole sequence where Haymitch wastes his time trying to protect a truly mindless little girl that the audience is supposed to care about.
What’s also frustrating is the ending: following the conclusion of the games, Lawrence’s depiction of what happens to Haymitch after he returns home is bleak, depressing, and superbly done. It’s a devastating sequence worth exploring more if this weren’t meant to be a popcorn blockbuster. And then Lawrence and crew add one more scene that ruins it all. Studio mandated? Maybe. An improvement? Quite the opposite.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is an overly long and unnecessary prequel that still manages to deliver some satisfying cold cuts. Whether that’s worth your time depends on your propensity for more of the same.
Review by Erik Samdahl. Erik is a marketing and technology executive by day, avid movie lover by night. He is a member of the Seattle Film Critics Society.